Showing posts with label Stephanie's Posts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stephanie's Posts. Show all posts

Sunday, November 16, 2014

Stephanie's Week 3 Response



Week 3 response

This week was a tough one, and after missing my meeting with my group and a meeting in class on Tuesday morning I had to catch up with what they were doing and talking about. I looked over the annotated bibliography to see what was posted and the Sculpt assignment and found some interesting information my other group members discovered, such as the Edo fire of 1657, and some of the information I sent to them via email. After meeting as a group again we looked over our materials and tried to narrow down exactly what it was we were looking for. We came across many materials about Chikamatsu’s life and the political atmosphere in Japan at the time, but as many times as the books and articles said that the Edo period was a time of peace, I spent an equal amount of time doubting it. After this insistence across our readings that this was a peaceful era I began to look for signs of dissent or discourse about the lower classes and what they faced. When there is power, there will always be somebody who is on the opposite end of that power—the lower classes, the dissenters, the oppressed—and I began to look for those who opposed that power and what happened to them. As I was reading though one of the books Jamie had, I discovered that the power of the Tokugawa government worked with the heads of the Confucian and Buddhist temples to create strict rules by which everybody should live by. I did find one article about dissent in the Edo period, but the amount of those who dissented seemed to be limited to that of peasants and only a few writers or artists and didn’t appear to include Chikamatsu (not yet, at least).

Surprisingly, the lower social classes seemed to be the ones to hold much of the economic power. We discovered that because of their material wealth, which they could not hold on to due to the strict Confucian social norms. As they had to spend the money they made right away, Bunraku and other arts flourished because of the money that could now freely be spent. According to one of my sources by Brian Powell, “In merchant society commercial survival in the special circumstances of low status and no political power but enormous economic influence depended on strict rules of social, business and personal conduct. Many of these rules were based on relationships of duty and obligation that were clearly understood and accepted as necessary by everyone,” (8). He goes on to describe the conflict people would have between their obligations and feelings and how this led into the development of the domestic play (sewamono) by Chikamatsu, which was a new genre that contained stories that people from the lower social classes could relate to. When we met in the library to discuss our assignment, this was a major part of the discussion and we decided to base our argument off of the fact that domestic plays, thanks the Chikamatsu, were a reason why Bunraku became so popular, and the popularity was due largely to the lower social classes, with their disposable income, who these plays were marketed towards.

Powell, Brian. “Japanese Theatre: Some Preliminaries.” Contemporary Theatre Review 1.2 (1994): 3-11. International Bibliography of Theatre & Dance with Full Text. Web. 15 Nov. 2014.

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Stephanie's Week 2 Journal



Our group split up work this week so each of us could focus on one aspect of the research and we could come together to report our findings. I went to the library website and searched for books about the Edo period and about other forms of art popular during that period in the hope that some similarity or connection could be found between the artistic trends of the time and the art of creating the dolls. Rose took on the art books and I searched through the history section and found several books dedicated to that period of Japanese history. Given that the Edo period lasted more than 200 years, I knew it would be hard to find exactly what I might want to look for in such a large time span, especially things relating to the specific time period or influencing the time period Chikamatsu lived in. I decided that once I did start to look through the books the best plan would be to either find his name or look though the index for references to the arts or specifically Bunraku. 

The Edo Inheritance was one of the books I picked up and began with an intriguing description of the Edo period, namely the fact that the beginning and the end of the peaceful period transitioned seamlessly from one to the next. The author, Tokugawa Tsunenari, notes that the characteristics of many ruling dynasties include the “rise from the chaos that that occurs towards the end of the previous dynasty’s rule. Once having come to power, the ruling dynasty will eventually reach it’s apogee, then start to decline and, in the end, disintegrate in to chaos, from which the next dynasty emerges” (10). It is no surprise then that, as I’ve read in another source, the Edo period is also characterized as a time in which the arts flourished. 

After an admittedly delayed reaction to the realization that a book on the Edo/Tokugawa era was written by a person named Tokugawa, I flipped back to the Preface and discovered that this person was indeed “the eighteenth head of the Tokugawa main lineage and a grandson of Tokugawa Iemasa, seventeenth head of the family, a former diplomat and the last speaker of Japan’s House of Peers,” (viii). Whoa. I read on and discovered that he was an adopted heir to the Tokugawa lineage but I could not find any mention as to the family he came from and whether or not it was another branch of the Tokugawa family he came from or from a distantly related line. Either way, it completely changed the way I read the book. Now I know he may be biased to favor the Tokugawa family and the actions of his ancestors, however, a few of the other readings we had about the Tokugawa era refer to it as a time of great peace and a golden age for the arts, so I know that he’s not alone when others share his sentiments. I also read that this book was written in Japanese and translated by Tokugawa Tsunenari’s son, Tokugawa Iehiro, which would explain the many usage/grammatical errors and awkward wording issues I ran across. By no means did it hinder my understanding of the book, but it did highlight the importance of reading or at least skimming a Preface/Introduction for important information. 

I did find it difficult to put this book down, it was fascinating. I know very little about Japanese history and Tokugawa’s writing just flowed so well and was so filled with emotion that it almost read like a novel. But I had to remind myself to look for the important stuff. I will come back to this book when I have time for leisurely reading. The information I did find that relates to the time period we are focusing on, Chikamatsu’s life span, was brief and not all that different from information we already found. It was a peaceful time, the Tokugawa shogunate was in charge, they had control over all of Japan and it was united at last after a long period of constant war, and the arts in Japan flourished. It was not such a great time for Christian missionaries or foreigners as they banned Christianity and closed their doors to outside trade except to the Dutch, but this closing off, which is sometimes viewed negatively, allowed artists to build upon their own skills and create things without much influence from outside cultures (there would, of course, always be influence from other cultures as theirs is built upon cultures from the mainland, namely China and Korea, but when closing their doors to outside trade the authors argues that the influx of cultural influence ceases and what is already there can be improved upon and a more “Japanese” culture can thrive as it evolves from the inside). 

From this point on I think I need to look for different viewpoints on history as many of my sources come from a more educated and artistic view on history. History, especially in the Tokugawa book, is discussed from a wider social and political perspective of how the government worked and how the arts prospered, but I have yet to read something from the viewpoint of the lower class. The Edo Inheritance discusses peasants and how they were better off under localized governments under the control of the Tokugawa instead of the Samurai warlords, but as I mentioned before, this book approaches history as it developed through the upper/ruling classes and only briefly mentions the lower classes and how they were affected.

Tokugawa, Tsunenari. The Edo Inheritance. Trans. Tokugawa Iehiro. Tokyo: International House of Japan. 2009. Print.

Sunday, November 2, 2014

Stephanie's Week 1 Reflection



This week we started our research into our topic of Bunraku. Our group decided to start searches individually and to come together again to discuss our findings. My initial searches began with the databases where I found plenty of articles dealing with various topics related to Bunraku and Japanese theatre in general. One of the first articles I came across dealt with the aesthetics of Japanese theatre, including Noh, Bunraku, and Kabuki. In it, the author, Alexander Alland Jr., discusses the roles of the actors and puppets in their genres and the traditions the actors follow while performing. He also goes on to compare the various styles and their relationships to religion and reality saying that Bunraku is more realistic than either Noh or Kabuki because the puppets are able to represent reality more than the actors on stage, “During battle scenes heads literally fly off bodies, sexual activity is sometimes rather vividly presented, and magical transformations such as a change from human to animal form are accomplished with relative ease,” (8).
A second intriguing source I came across deals with Modern Bunraku plays and the author’s experiences with Bunraku puppets and the theatre. The majority of the article focuses on the modern performances of the Otome Bunraku troupe which is comprised entirely of female puppeteers. I was fascinated by this article because she mentions that males were the only ones allowed to operate Bunraku puppets traditionally, but this changed in about 1900 when the proprietors of Bunraku theatres sought a larger audience. Unlike the men who use three people to operate a puppet, Otome Bunraku operators only use one person. Although men are a part of the Otome troupe, only women are allowed on stage. Her article features pictures and drawings of the traditional Bunraku puppet operators and the Otome operators and shows how their bodies are attached to the puppet in order to operate it. In her interview with Michiko Hirano of the Japan Society I noticed a similarity between how the puppeteers treat the puppets and how the Noh actors treated their masks, Hirano says of the puppeteers “…they try to feel and understand how the doll feels. And they move themselves according to what the puppet is feeling,” (18). Similarly, in Alland’s article he says “Just as the mask must come to life through the Noh actor who wears it, the Bunraku puppet must come to life through its chief operator,” (Alland, 8).
 I used these two articles as my primary examples when our group met on Friday night to discuss and come to a final decision about our topic. Our possible topics included things such as Bunraku puppets and the influence on modern Anime, the role of Bunraku in Japanese pop culture, older Bunraku plays being adapted in contemporary Japan, the connection of Bunraku to Buddhism, contemporary Bunraku troupes (including Otome), and the origins of Bunraku. We finally agreed to focus on one of the more famous Bunraku playwrights, Chikamatsu, primarily because his name popped up in most of the articles and books we read about Bunraku. In fact, every history book about Bunraku and Japanese theatre mentioned him somewhere. From what I recall from a source one of my group mates found, his repertoire includes over one hundred plays. From that point, we decided to focus mostly on his life as a playwright and to find one of his more popular plays to study as well. Overall, I feel that our research and reading from the first two thirds of class has helped me to practice focusing on specific areas of study and to find the discrepancies in one person’s “history” of a certain topic versus another person’s. While conducting my research this week I had an eye out for anything that seems contradictory or very different to another author’s account of Bunraku and the history of the art. I am still on the lookout for such an occurrence and I will continue to read my sources closely.
Alland, Alexander Jr. “The Construction of Reality and Unreality in Japanese Theatre.” The Drama Review, Performance Theory: Southeast Asia Issue. 23:2 (Jun. 1979) pp. 3-10. Web. 28 Oct. 2014.
Skipitares, Theodora. “The Tension of Modern Bunraku.” PAJ: A Journal of Performance and Art. 76:1 (2004) pp. 13-21. Web. 29 Oct 2014.